Guide

Laying to a stake vs laying to a risk

When you lay a horse on an exchange you are taking a bet from someone who wants to back it. If the horse loses, you keep their stake. If it wins, you pay them their winnings. How much you stand to lose depends on the price, and that is why staking a lay needs more thought than staking a back bet.

The two numbers in every lay

  • The backer's stake is what you win if the horse is beaten, less commission.
  • Your liability is what you pay if the horse wins. It equals the backer's stake multiplied by the price minus one.

Lay a horse at 3.0 for a £10 stake and your liability is £20. Lay one at 1.5 for a £10 stake and your liability is £5. The win is the same in both cases. The risk is four times bigger in the first.

Laying to a fixed stake

You accept the same backer's stake every time. We call this lay to 1pt stake.

  • Horse beaten: you win 0.95pt (1pt less 5% commission).
  • Horse wins at 2.0: you lose 1pt.
  • Horse wins at 4.0: you lose 3pt.

It is simple, and every winning lay pays the same. The drawback is that your losses vary a lot. One winner at 4.0 wipes out more than three successful lays. A run of winning favourites at bigger prices produces a deep dip.

Laying to a fixed risk

You size each bet so the most you can lose is the same every time. We call this lay to risk 1pt. The stake you accept is 1 divided by the price minus one.

  • At 2.0 you accept a 1pt stake. Beaten: win 0.95pt. Wins: lose 1pt.
  • At 4.0 you accept a 0.33pt stake. Beaten: win 0.32pt. Wins: lose 1pt.
  • At 1.5 you accept a 2pt stake. Beaten: win 1.90pt. Wins: lose 1pt.

Now every loss is identical and your wins vary. You are putting more weight on short-priced horses and less on longer ones.

Same bets, different results

The two methods can give different answers from the same set of bets, and it depends on where the winners fall.

We looked at all 6,868 UK and Irish races from 16 December 2025 to 14 September 2026 with a sole favourite at 4.0 or shorter at Betfair SP. Laying every one of them blind, with 5% commission:

  • Lay to 1pt stake: lost 1.9% per bet.
  • Lay to risk 1pt: lost 0.8% per point risked.

Both lose, which is the first lesson: laying favourites with no selection is a losing game, just as backing them all is. The market is efficient enough that commission decides it.

The second lesson is in the price bands. For favourites shorter than 1.5, laying to a stake lost 0.8% while laying to a risk lost 8.6%. At those prices fixed-risk staking has you accepting very large stakes on horses that win three times in four. Between 1.5 and 2.0 the position reversed: fixed risk returned +4.8% against +3.7% for fixed stake.

Which should you use?

  • Fixed stake suits you if the bets are mostly at similar prices and you want a record that is easy to follow.
  • Fixed risk suits you if you need to cap every loss, for example because your bank is small or you cannot sit through a deep dip. It gives a smoother ride at bigger prices.
  • Be careful with fixed risk at very short prices. Below about 1.5 the stakes you accept become large and a short losing run is expensive.

Whichever you choose, decide before you start and keep to it. Switching methods after a bad week is how a sound approach gets turned into a losing one.

Why we show both

Every lay model in our members area is published both ways, side by side, with the worst losing run and the deepest dip for each. The bets are the same. The experience of following them is different, and you should see both before deciding how you would stake them.

Free every morning

Free value horse racing tips.

One selection a day in your inbox, free, picked from our five models. Every bet settled at Betfair SP and kept on the record, winners and losers alike.

Want every model? See the full portfolio → · £15 for your first month